Study Number: 

1003

Project Title:

Seedling recruitment in artificial gaps.

Investigator(s):

Brian Beckage   E-Mail | Tel. 919.477.8542 | Beckage website
James Clark  E-Mail |
Tel. 919.660.7402 | Biographical Sketch | The Clark Lab
Affiliated Institution(s): Duke University                        
Address: Duke University  
Department of Biology
Durham, North Carolina  27708  USA
Study Type: Terrestrial
Project Type: Coweeta Core Research
Study Period:

06/1993 - 06/2000

Status/Notes:

Type 1  Project complete, no further edits. 

Funding Sources:

National Science Foundation, DEB-9632854 (Text Version) and DEB-0218001 (Text Version) to Coweeta LTER.

Abstract: We examined the role of both intermediate-sized gaps and a dense shrub layer on subsequent tree seedling recruitment in a southern Appalachian deciduous forest. We monitored the density of tree seedlings in twelve artificial gaps and adjacent canopy controls under two contrasting understory conditions. Half of the experimental gaps were dominated by the dense, shade-producing shrub, Rhododendron maximum, while the remaining gaps were relatively open. Canopy gaps 20 m in diameter were created by girdling canopy trees, leaving standing dead trees with minimal disturbance to the understory. Density of first-year and first-year seedlings was monitored in transects extending from adjacent undisturbed forest through the experimental gaps.


Resources for students about terms used in this study:
Rhododendron maximum - Source: USDA Plants Database
Southern Appalachian Deciduous Forests - Source: Coweeta LTER
Gap studies - Coweeta LTER
Location(s), Described: Upper (Watershed 27) and Lower (Watershed 18) Gap Plots
Location(s):
Elevation
Decimal Degrees
UTM, Zone 17, NAD83
Transect
ln1
ln2
ln3
lr1
lr2
lr3
un1
un2
un3
ur1
ur2
ur3
Latitude
-83.43
-83.43
-83.43
-83.43
-83.43
-83.43
-83.46
-83.46
-83.46
-83.46
-83.46
-83.461072
Longitude
35.050926
35.051346
35.050583
35.051512
35.051600
35.051837
35.038191
35.038569
35.038711
35.038149
35.038408
35.037922
UTM X
278209.53
278239.28
278229.96
278223.71
278241
278172.87
275471.84
275482.93
275460.06
275500.65
75519.09
275501.75
UTM Y
3881394.70
3881441.50
3881357.50
3881459.00
3881468.50
3881497.50
3880049.00
3880089.20
3880105.20
3880041.20
3880071.00
3880017.20
Location(s), Download GPS: ArcView Shape Files (.shp):  UTM, NAD83, Zone 17  | Lat/Lon
Location(s), Online Maps: USGS Topographic Maps of research sites for this project
(Printable for fieldwork)

 

Methods/Experimental Design: Our clusters of experimental gaps were located in two mixed oak stands that bracket the elevation range of this community, hereafter referred to as low elevation (850 m) and high elevation (1100 m) sites. Sites had a northeast aspect and slopes ranged from 30% to 50% (high elevation) and from 45% to 70% (low elevation). At both sites, we established six plots (12 plots total), each corresponding to a single experimental gap. Three of the six plots at each elevation had a dense Rhododendron maximum understory, while three plots lacked Rhododendron maximum. Rhododendron maximum has a patchy distribution at these sites, permitting us to locate experimental gaps (with and without Rhododendron maximum) in close proximity, thus allowing for consistent overstory composition, slope, soils, and microclimate.

Locations for experimental gaps were selected in 1991, and canopy trees were marked for girdling to produce gaps of approximately 300 m2 (expanded gap definition, Runkle 1981). Up to five trees from a variety of species were girdled to create each gap. A transect, comprised of 40 contiguous 1 m2 quadrats, was established across each planned gap. Transects were generally oriented in a north-south direction. Transects included 20 central quadrats exposed to gap conditions and 20 outer quadrats subtended by the surrounding canopy. There were a few exceptions to this layout, due to topographic considerations or patchiness of the Rhododendron maximum. In these cases, transects deviated from a north-south orientation or were interrupted to maintain consistent understory conditions (e.g., Rhododendron maximum or non Rhododendron maximum). Following collection of pretreatment data in 1993, we produced experimental canopy gaps by girdling trees in late summer of the same year. The herbicide Garlon was applied to trees that leafed out the following spring. Girdled trees remained standing for the duration of our study, although large branches began to fall in the 4th year.

We censused tree seedlings along all transects annually in July or August from 1993 to 1997. We identified all seedlings and saplings less than 2 m tall to genus or species (for Acer rubrum, Liriodendron tulipifera, and Quercus prinus). Seedlings classified as Betula spp were likely Betula lenta, because Betula allegheniensis is restricted to the highest elevations at Coweeta. We were unable to confidently differentiate all seedlings of Quercus velutina, Quercus coccinea, and Quercus rubra, so these are grouped as Quercus rubra-type.
Sampling Frequency: Yearly
Data Columns:

Quadrant - Quadrant ID
Year - Year
Age_Class - Age_Class
ln1 - lower elevation non-Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings
ln2 - lower elevation non-Rhododendron transect 2; number of seedlings/samplings
ln3 - lower elevation non-Rhododendron transect 3; number of seedlings/samplings
lr1 - lower elevation Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings
lr2 - lower elevation Rhododendron transect 2; number of seedlings/samplings
lr3 - lower elevation Rhododendron transect 3; number of seedlings/samplings
un1 - upper elevation non-Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings
un2 - upper elevation non-Rhododendron transect 2; number of seedlings/samplings
un3 - upper elevation non-Rhododendron transect 3; number of seedlings/samplings
ur1 - upper elevation Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings
ur2 - upper elevation Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings
ur3 - upper elevation Rhododendron transect 1; number of seedlings/samplings

Publications:

Beckage, Brian, J. S. Clark, B. Clinton, and B. Haines. 2000. A long-term study of tree seedling recruitment in Southern Appalachian forests: the effects of canopy gaps and shrub understories. Canadian Journal of Forest Research. 30: 1617-1631.

Beckage, Brian. 2000. Seedling Recruitment in Southern Appalachian Forests: Does Spatial Heterogeneity Maintain Species Diversity?
Ph.D. Dissertation. Duke University.

Data Restrictions: Users must adhere to the Coweeta LTER Data Policy.
Metadata: EML Format (XML Schema) | Information about EML
Data Downloads: Microsoft® Excel (.xls)
DBase (.dbf)